Skip to content

Curry by Naben Ruthnum: Reflections on Food, Identity, and Nostalgia

  • by

Naben Ruthnum’s Curry: Eating, Reading, and Race is not, in the end, a book about food. It is about the expectations built around food, the stories that orbit a single word—“curry”—and the narrow corridor that so many South Asian writers are funneled into when they publish in the West. Nostalgia becomes the demanded currency, authenticity the gatekeeper. Ruthnum traces how “curry books”—memoirs thick with longing for a homeland, mothers’ kitchens, and cultural touchstones—have come to dominate the space, often at the expense of other voices and other ways of being. It is a careful examination of what these stories do and don’t allow, and of how limiting it can be when identity is reduced to a set of flavors that, in truth, only exists in restaurants.

The book blends literary criticism with cultural commentary and personal insight, pushing back against these stereotypes, questioning who gets to define “authentic” identity and why writers of color are often boxed into telling the same story over and over.  Ruthnum’s refusal to indulge nostalgia feels almost radical, not because it denies history, but because it denies sentimentality as the only way of accessing it. He suggests that the homeland so many memoirs claim to recover never truly existed to begin with—at least not in the way it is imagined on the page. To step into that memory is to step into a river that has already changed, already moved beyond recognition.

Curry is sharp, honest, and unwilling to settle for easy sentiment. It recognizes how seductive and neatly marketable nostalgia can be, but insists on looking at the gaps, the silences, and the more complicated truths of diasporic experience. In doing so, Ruthnum opens up space for those of us who do not feel tethered by memory, who do not cook with ghosts at our shoulders, who do not wish to perform the same stories for an audience’s sake. Instead, it asks near existential questions: what happens when the home you long for never really existed, or when the food that is supposed to anchor you doesn’t actually stir your heart at all?

It turns out that the resonance lies not in sharing the same origin, but in sharing the same refusal: a refusal of nostalgia, a refusal of the easy story of homecoming. And that is where his book touches my own experience most closely – because I, too, am someone without nostalgia for a “cultural homeland”.

Like Ruthnum, I don’t look back at childhood meals or cultural traditions with a longing heart. Food wasn’t memory for me. It wasn’t love or inheritance. I do not recall the scent of broth simmering in my parents’ house, nor do I conjure family dinners as sacred rituals. Until well into adulthood, food was merely sustenance, never a vessel for longing for a time or place. Ruthnum articulates a silence I had been carrying for decades, the quiet unease of never quite finding myself in the mire of cultural memoirs. It makes no difference that he writes from a South Asian perspective while mine is East Asian; for what binds us is not heritage but absence. The absence of homecoming. The lack of longing or belonging.

It is a strange relief to realize that this absence is not mine alone. Over the years, I sometimes wondered if there was something wrong with me. While my college peers were homesick for their mother’s cooking and eagerly awaited for the next holiday to return home, I was more than content to eat late night pizza and excited to try chocolate soft serve cones at the new dorm cafeteria. Surrounded by these same voices in both life and literature, the latter polished with tropes of authenticity and homeland, I felt guilty for my indifference. Should I mourn a place I never missed? Should I hunger for food that tastes of origins I did not treasure?

So I avoided reading the stereotypical books authored by immigrant children wrestling with cultural identity, especially memoirs about rediscovering their homeland. It’s tough to verbally acknowledge the topic holds little significance for me. It almost feels…callous, when so many others care seem to care so deeply. It makes me feel as if I’m somehow inadequate, for all the wrong reasons.

This is not to say that I don’t engage with Asian cultural traditions. Of course I love the food, and also have a deep appreciation for Asian art. Even traditional festivities and cultural celebrations are fun. But I cannot pretend that they are a bridge to belonging. Celebrating Lunar New Year feels as foreign and familiar to me as cooking a turkey for Thanksgiving. Neither holiday stirs anything in me. It doesn’t heal the nonexistent hole in my heart. It doesn’t make me miss “home”, wherever that may be. Because the truth is, I don’t remember any of them that fondly in the first place.

Nevertheless, I do secretly have a place for nostalgia in my heart. For the past decade, when someone inevitably asked “Where are you from?” My reply was Oakland and the San Francisco Bay Area, because it was the first and only place where I understood the meaning of belonging.

The first two decades of my life were spent mostly eating at home to save money, though my father would far too often come home with the dreaded 3-for-99 cent hardshell tacos with ground beef and shredded “taco cheese” (what passed for Mexican food in our household), or the occasional “million dollar burger” from Carl’s Jr. that never lived up to its name. If we went out, it was either the same dimsum place where our relatives gathered every month, or another Chinese restaurant whose main appeal was the gigantic portions of Yangchow fried rice for $9, or on the rarest occasion, a Korean BBQ restaurant with beautiful wooden interiors.

Graduating college at the height of a recession meant that sacrifices had to be made, or my chance at freedom would end before it ever began. So I quickly found a low-paying but none too strenuous IT job, and spent the first year living off whole wheat toast at the office Monday through Friday, with boiled chicken and broccoli as my occasional for dinner, which was quite a feat in my converted garage apartment with no actual kitchen. But I was finally a real adult, and I had the freedom to choose what to eat, what to taste, and what to spend my own very hard-earned money on.

Back then, Oakland was rising as a haven for chefs priced out of San Francisco, who began opening restaurants where they actually lived rather than across the bay. At a time when I was too broke to travel the world, the Bay brought the world to me through food. It wasn’t only the taste of freedom, but of discovery—the beginning of my journey and love affair with food. My first foie gras, rich and silken, a perfect contrast to the charcoal grilled steak beneath. A lobster roll in Half Moon Bay, drenched in butter, overflowing with sweet meat. Raw oysters and clams, briny and alive with the taste of the ocean. French food that wasn’t Marie Callender’s, elegant in its simplicity. Bread pudding, so dense and warm fresh out of the oven, drizzled with raspberry sauce. Watermelon brightened into a salad with herbs and feta cheese. Grilled sandwiches pressed until the cheese ran into the bread. Fresh flaky scones of cheddar, jalapeno, and seasonal fruits from an underground bakery. Chicken cooked under a brick, its skin seared crisp, its meat tender.

Every Friday for happy hour, I would hitch a ride with coworkers to a brewery. As you may gather from the name of this blog, I wasn’t there for the beer. In the parking lot, a man named Jim hauled in a van, a wood-fired brick pizza oven he had built by hand, and made pizzas with the freshest local ingredients of the day. I visited so religiously that he joked about naming a pizza after me. He was just starting out this business from scratch, and felt like a kindred spirit. I still remember my favorite order: prosciutto, provolone, and paper thin slices of golden potatoes that turned halfway into crisps in the extreme heat. I’ve never found this pizza anywhere since. That was Oakland to me: improvised, defiant, alive.

On Alameda, a sushi master from Japan set up an eight-seat counter in the upstairs room of a nondescript building with no signage. Chopsticks, soy sauce, and cellphones were forbidden contraband. Once I cajoled a friend who only ate meat to accompany me, and thus introduced him to the dazzling world of fresh seafood which he can now thoroughly appreciate.

Further inland, a plate of golden fried chicken wings, deboned and stuffed with turmeric vermicelli noodles, captured my heart. It was my introduction to Cambodian food, and I haven’t let go since. I’ve looked for this exact dish in other Cambodian or Southeast Asian restaurants across the US, but it simply doesn’t exist on menus outside of the Bay, more than likely due to the labor it takes to prepare such a dish.

Elsewhere in East Oakland, at some small risk to ourselves, my friend and I would visit our favorite taco truck. What made it special was the way they lightly fried each tortilla before topping it, a care few others took. I always ordered carnitas, still a favorite of mine, alongside lengua and cabeza. At $1.25 per taco, I had no doubt it was a better deal than the 3-for-99 cent Del Tacos where somehow all the components tasted vaguely like cardboard. The only downside was that you could only go for lunch, in broad daylight.

Of course, San Francisco had its own set of discoveries. In Embarcadero, I ate my first ahi tuna burger at Grott’s with zero hesitation. While I’m not normally a fan of giant slabs of uncut tuna, the steak-like texture especially when lightly seared on both sides works surprisingly well in a brioche bun.

Well, I could go on. Each meal was a revelation. Not because it was necessarily extravagant, but because it was mine — mine to choose, mine to savor, mine to remember as the first tastes of freedom and discovery, fleeting but unforgettable. But when I look back now, what lingers is not just the food, but the ache of having left the Bay Area before I was ready. Just like the song says, I left my heart in San Francisco. Though in truth, I left it scattered across the Bay. And it was not a romantic leaving, not a bittersweet farewell tied neatly with memory. It was unwilling, unresolved, like a story unfinished, a chapter closed mid-sentence. That incompleteness gave the place its sentimental weight.

On nostalgia, Ruthnum brings up the old saying: “You can’t step in the same river twice”. A search for  search for self and happiness tied to a place in memory will almost always end in disappointment. The “home” you long for often never existed in the first place, at least not in the way you imagined it. What you find instead is a hollowness, the slow realization that you no longer belong. It is a truth that lingers, because even knowing it doesn’t stop you from trying. We return anyway, hoping to find what once felt like ours, hoping that memory might hold steady against time.

I finally returned to the Bay after more than a decade away—not to relive my youth with brashness, but with quiet steps, hoping simply to walk down memory lane. On my very first outing, disappointment was ready to greet me. My favorite cafe, which baked the best cookies with chocolate chips that melted even at room temperature, had closed its doors only three months earlier. It was as if the city conspired to tell me: you cannot return, not even for this.

Oakland itself had changed. The pandemic stripped the city bare, leaving blocks emptier, quieter, except for Chinatown. Even there, the irony was bitter: when I lived beside it, I rarely went. My resistance to nostalgia kept me elsewhere, eating from taco trucks in East Oakland, savoring Mexican food for the first time, discovering things I had never had growing up. That mattered far more than clinging to the familiar. That remains true now: it is freedom that I taste in those memories, not childhood.

But when I returned, the people were gone. The places I loved had dissolved. Nostalgia cannot live in absence; it requires the living pulse of what was. And so I learned for the first time what Ruthnum wrote: the home we think we long for never existed. The truth is simpler and harder—it was never about the city, nor heritage, nor nostalgia. It was about a moment in time that cannot be repeated.

The sushi counter has closed, its master retired. The Cambodian angel wings remain, but lighter, less crisp, less spiced. But was it really – or did the excitement of discovery season my memories? My taco truck has disappeared, for which I can only hope for the best. The tuna steak burger at Grott’s has shrunk against the tides of inflation. Jim, the pizza man, now owns a proper takeout shop with ovens, his van gone to disrepair. He wasn’t in the kitchen when I visited, and I wonder if he would have remembered me. Perhaps it’s better I never found out; I don’t think I could stand another heartbreak.

And while I’m sure new taco trucks and pizza pop ups have taken their place, I wasn’t looking for discovery. I wasn’t seeking newness. That’s not why I visited Oakland, because I could have searched for that anywhere else in the world. Even after five trips across Italy, I still haven’t found another pizza to call my favorite.

I only wanted what turned out to be the most impossible of all: another bite of that chocolate chip cookie, its warmth as fleeting as the first taste of freedom in my youth.  But like the river Ruthnum describes, the Bay itself had already shifted. The tide had gone out, washing away the people, the places, and the moments that once defined it for me. I left with the quiet knowledge that I will never again enter that water as it once was. My chapter, closed prematurely, still hangs open in memory. Its last line unwritten, the tether to youth washed away by the current of time, leaving only the memory of discoveries that can never be repeated, faint and irretrievable, like water slipping through open hands.

Spread the love